Skip to main content

the anonymous life (sex wednesday)

By September 30, 2009Blog

What the Sex Industry and Church have in common

When I was a senior in college my roommate and I decided to visit the World’s Largest Adult Bookstore. Believe it or not, that’s in Nashville. I had never been to any sort of “adult” store before, so I was quite overwhelmed and intrigued and appalled that, for some people, Adult Bookstore shopping was a regular occurrence. As I walked through the front door a woman with 22 earrings dangling from various places on the left side of her cheek said “welcome, guys.” Aw, I thought, it’s just like we’re shopping at Sears, except the greeter looked like a vampire.

I was too nervous/guilty to say anything back to her. I didn’t even look at her. In fact I pretended not to hear her. I didn’t want her to remember my face and decide to wave at me if the two of us happened to run into each other at Applebees or the next time I was shopping for coffins. No Christian wants to be recognized in public as the man who frequents Satan’s Pornography Warehouse.

At the time, I was not all that experienced in the ways of filling my head with naked imagery doing things with other naked imagery. Sure, I had witnessed a couple of adult films, but on both of those occasions, I wasn’t the one who had braved sneaking into the back room of the video store and then walking up to the register and renting them. I wouldn’t have done it. It required one to be both courageous and evil on the same day. And that rarely happened for me.

As I browsed the aisles of the World’s Largest Adult Bookstore, I couldn’t help but notice the people around me. Most of them seemed to lurk around the store rather than walk. No one looked around. They hid their faces behind magazines or kept them pointed toward dark corners. It seemed everybody was wishing for the same thing, for the power to delve into their personal fetishes without being seen.

Everybody in that store other than the vampire woman would have done just about anything for the ability to be invisible and enjoy the decadence of our surroundings. To walk the aisles unseen would have made the experience ideal–to be there among the truck drivers, college students, and youth pastors as an anonymous human being.

Eventually, we got our wish–the Internet.

As the world connected online, the Internet offered people anonymity, a beautiful hiding place behind the almighty I.P. address.

In regards to online pornography, anonymous is a rather powerful tool.

In most online situations–whether it’s making comments on blogs or stalking people or checking in on old boyfriends or girlfriends or enemies, or engaging a sexual fetish of our choosing–Anonymous is a state of being that offers us the ability to “be” without the ramifications or the aftermath.

When it’s over and we’ve had our fill of whatever it is that fancies our minds and bodies, we can simply disappear and go back to our “realities.”

Christians talk a good bit about pornography and sexuality. We talk a lot about the lust part and the masturbation part and how it affects our relationships. We discuss the addictions, the guilt, and the gimmicks to help us find a path toward healing.

But it’s rare that we discuss the “anonymity” part.

Sure, it gets touched on from time to time. But I don’t think we really know or comprehend the power and lure that “being anonymous” really offers people.

And I think we need to talk about it.

Why? Because many of us find a great deal of fulfillment in being anonymous.

For some of us the ability to remain “anonymous” is the selling point to engaging porn or sexual fantasy online. Having the “thrill” of the World’s Largest Adult Bookstore in the comfort of our bedroom and getting to peruse it without fear of being seen or heard is a beautiful commodity. The “not getting caught” part is likely the only reason some of us ever get involved in looking at porn online in the first place. Most of us wouldn’t have the balls to walk into a strip club or an adult bookstore–SOMEBODY MIGHT SEE US OR RECOGNIZE US–but as “anonymous” we work up the courage to “be” and “do” anything we want online. It’s there, as an unknown and invisible presence, we get the chance to be what we believe might be “us” and experience a little short-lived “freedom.” However, “anonymity” isn’t simply about hiding. Not for all of us.

For some of us, “being anonymous” helps us find our story. Maybe it’s not our story, but it’s a story. You might be surprised by this, but not everybody engages online pornography just to “get off” or “reach climax.” Even if the “conclusion” happens after an orgasm, it doesn’t mean the journey of “getting there” was about reaching an orgasm. Some of us are looking for a story, a little excitement to either fuel our ability to live or numb us from whatever pain we’re feeling. Pornography offers an escape, and being anonymous gives us the freedom and strength to walk many paths that we wouldn’t ordinarily walk, and sometimes we find a familiar thread of a “story” that we chase after. The truth is, some of us spend hours engaging the “story.” And it’s not for the orgasm.

For some of us, “being anonymous” fuels our imaginations. While in the real world, we’re overweight and average with a small penis. In the online world, we are “SexyMan615.” He’s handsome with muscles and hung like a donkey. With this new identity we are able to go online and meet “Luscious36D,” a flat-chested middle-aged woman from Nebraska who hasn’t been on a date in years. But in our imaginations, she’s beautiful and he says the all the right things.

For some of us, “being anonymous” makes us feel at home. In the “real world” our sexual fantasies often alienate us. To mention aloud what we like and don’t like often brings embarrassment or judgment . But online, we learn that we’re really not that strange after all. We feel normal when find that seemingly lots of people are into the same fantasies that we are. And oddly, we feel less like an outsider when we’re alone in our homes chatting with people who like the same things we do or watching people engage in the same sexual activity that we want to engage. But we don’t know these people. And they don’t know us. And we like it that way.

For some of us, “being anonymous” helps us find a community. Some of us live two different lives, the one we live in the “real world” and the one we live “online.” The people we “know” or “meet” in our online world often know more about us than our friends and family know. Sexual fantasy or fetishes or “issues” often create a strong bond between people. Though we may not know each other’s first names, often we feel a kinship to the “anonymous stories” of the people we meet. Whether we want to admit it or not, some of us think of it as a part of our community.

Pursuing our sexual fantasies online as anonymous definitely has its benefits: A safe place. Story. Fuel for our imaginations. Home. Community. (And a lot more.) Today’s sex industry “sells” far more than simply naked people doing things with other naked people. It sells a way of life.

And in a way, it sells the same exact things that churches sell. Sure, they do it differently. And sometimes they do it better.

“But wait, that’s not fair; the fulfillment a person finds online is plastic and fake,” some of you might argue.

And if that’s you’re argument, I certainly understand where you’re coming from. But in a lot of ways, the argument only makes the comparison stronger.

Because in reality, the porn industry has more in common with the church than some might realize.

Not only do they sell a lot of the same ideas, many of us who go to church every Sunday, do so as anonymous people. Sure, church members know our names and faces and certain parts of our stories, but they don’t really know us. We fear what would happen if they really knew us.

So parts of our lives remain anonymous, invisible to the outside world. And many of us, have become so used to hiding behind “fake smiles” and “I.P. address” that we’re okay with being anonymous. Frankly, we prefer it.

So I ask, are you living anonymously?

**Please feel free to leave anonymous comments. I don’t want this post’s topic to limit the conversation.

Share/Save/Bookmark

Viagra is for the treatment of inability to get or keep an erection and similar states when erection is of low quality. When you buy remedies like cialis from canada you should know about cialis online canada. It may have a lot of brands, but only one ATC Code. Erectile dysfunction, defined as the persistent impossibility to maintain a satisfactory erection, affects an estimated 15 to 30 millions men in the America alone. Sexual health is an substantial part of a man’s life, no problem his age etc.

Matthew Paul Turner

Author Matthew Paul Turner

More posts by Matthew Paul Turner

Join the discussion 40 Comments

  • ttm says:

    I’m struggling lately because I am craving anonymity in my small group. I’m tired of being honest about what I really think and having people in the group look at me as if I am strange and fetish-plagued for what I believe about the Bible or God or politics or the world. I’m tired of being told that my views aren’t valid because they don’t match church group-think. I’m tired of my views being used as litmus tests for my salvation and measures of someone else’s idea of spiritual maturity.

    When I’m honest and really seeking to have questions answered–looking for the next wrinkle in my story or still entangled in the last one–these people make me feel dirty for doing it. When I’m not honest–when I sit there silently and they think I agree with the B.S. being spouted in the “name of God”–my own conscience makes me feel dirty.

    So if I speak up, I’m labeled strange and dirty (“Liberal” or “Heretic”) and if I don’t speak up, I feel strange and dirty (“Hypocrite” or “Coward”). What’s a girl to do? The only sensible thing seems to run…

    If I run to the arms of God, I know that even though I am strange and dirty (and so are you), everything will be fresh and clean again. But there aren’t very many Christians that I find myself running toward these days. Most Christians only want to be my friend if I’m theologically brilliant, financially able and willing to support their pet causes, and agree with every jot and tittle of their assessment of what makes a “TRUE” Christian. Otherwise, I might as well go lurk at the adult store.

    At least there I might strike up a relationship with someone a little more like me–flawed and seeking something more, but not needing to shop in the costume section because I’ve already purchased, used, and tried out every available mask.

  • Danny Bixby says:

    This goes down as ‘best post you’ve ever written.’

    Thank you for writing this.

  • John says:

    @ttm, My wife and I understand where you are coming from. We feel it too but didn’t know how to put it down in words. Your thoughts and feelings are like ours.

    @Danny, I couldn’t agree with you more.

    @Matthew, I reposted this and will probably cause some controversy with my “Christian” friends. But, I can handle it. This is a very good post. Keep ’em coming and I will share them with all my “friends.”

  • Jen says:

    Unlike the first comment, I desire to be known by those around me because sometimes I feel misunderstood when I say something. I want my church family to know the brokenness I came from because I want them to real truly see the change in me. Only a few people in my church truly know me. I want that to change because if they truly know who I am, then I pray I will truly know who they are.

    We are a many membered body and I believe that if I come out from my anonymity, then someone else will hopefully be encouraged to do so as well. We are all broken people and I think sometimes we don’t always see that. I’d like to see that change but it has to start with me.

    Thanks for sharing.

  • PaulKordon says:

    Not bad there Matty!

  • nugg33 says:

    Yep. You hit the nail on the head there.

    Maybe porn isn’t the problem. Maybe not being able to be real in front of others is the problem. Maybe if we felt comfortable telling our friends that we want to look at porn, or we have fetishes and fantasies, then the fact we are being real in front of others would mean we wouldn’t need to go looking for ways to feel real.

    Porn is a problem for me. And I am learning more and more that maybe the reason I am drawn to it is because I want to feel good about myself and ‘being anonymous’ allows me to feel complete.

    I think the more I am real with my accountability partner, the more I will feel good about myself and my identity and so won’t be left wanting.

  • Anonymous says:

    Is anyone really real these days?
    We can write on our blogs and talk about how we want to be known and understood. How others lable us this and that and to be honest, I don’t want to be fucking known. Cause if I was to be honest with who I am, I would have a lot of changing to do. I don’t want to face the shame of who I am or what I have done.
    We all would.
    To the author of this blog. Are you honest?
    To the ones who posted comments. Are you honest?

  • Bill Todd says:

    Matt, you’re telling the truth.

    What are you thinking? If we tell the truth, and even worse, listen to each others truth w/o feeling the need to fix or correct them, who knows what could happen?

    Authenticity? Soul deep connection? Trust? or worst of all…

    change?

  • for once i am not going to argue with you. haha. no but really, fantastic post, Matthew. i lived anonymously in my addiction to porn for a long, long time. and when i wasn’t addicted anymore, i still lived anonymously… but in the church, never wanting to expose this part of who i was.

    the church should be the safest place for someone to share a struggle, but instead, it is the most dangerous. whether or not a person would be judged, is based on the church they go to — but the fear is there regardless. the what if.

    i don’t know how this can be fixed. i guess the only way it really can is by people like you and me — sharing our own brokenness, or own struggles, or own failings. breaking down the walls of shame so grace can prevail and freedom can be found.

  • jeff says:

    It is pretty simple really…the evil one’s playgroung is in isolation…this is how he works…by keeping us isolated from each other, or our God he wins…we must live in the world of relationship…relationship with each other and with God…when two or three are gathered in his name…the evil one is defeated! Be real, get into thr word and get into relationship!

  • ah440z says:

    I attempted to post earlier….but obviously it didn’t work….I have HONESTLY never had a problem with porn I have looked at it…but do not see the need for it when i can an conjer up any images I need in my mind without a problem. I am kinda surprised that christians have a problem with porn cause the only people that I know that look at it are non-christians and they do not see it as a problem. Especially seeing on here at least one woman having at least at one time or another been into porn. that to me is a new one…but then again maybe others that I know are not being honest. I definitely enjoyed tmm’s post specifically where she said “At least there I might strike up a relationship with someone a little more like me–flawed and seeking something more, but not needing to shop in the costume section because I’ve already purchased, used, and tried out every available mask”….I think the church has a lot of people wearing masks….I know my opinions of church would not be welcomed…..i question the guilt imposed “tithing crap ” I question when the church is tight on $$$ the janitor gets the boot not the overpaid pastors who have never even taken the time to say hello or email the majority of the flock…why if the church supports missionsaries are the individuals who go on those trips have to raise their own $$$ ??? I am involved in a small group that is using the book “one month to live” I find that most chapters have one good point and the rest is a lot of fluff….coulda fit in a pamphlet and stillgot the same enjoyment….I do not think that would be received wellif I were HONEST among the masks !!!

  • Tam says:

    im not one who has ever struggled with porn addiction – but when you compare it to church – i can identify with that.

    brilliant post, matthew.

  • Jennifer says:

    Sometimes I have the hardest time putting down to words what I really want to say. And there, I said it! (just trying to be authentic). But, what a thought provoking post and probably more truth to it then most of us would like to or dare admit.

    For sure though, pornography is just another lie we humans consume in hopes of filling the gaping hole. Church too sometimes. I think we go there (Church) in hopes of connecting, but if we can’t or aren’t allowed to be real… how then can we truly be known, or for that matter, find what we really need to fill our souls? It seems to me authentic community, along with Christ, is the only true answer, especially when it comes to the problem of anomnity.

    Brings to mind when I dared, (and believe me, at the time, this was a HUGE stretch for me) attend a small group for sex addicts. Actually, the group was for anyone with relational and/or “sexual” issues so that made it a little more plausible. After all, I was only going because my then (now ex-husband) was struggling with his own case of sexual addiction. When I showed up I showed up with the mentality, “I really don’t need to be here,” expecting to be sectioned off with the other wives of “sex” addicts. Instead, the group leader quickly saw through me and put me in the group labled, “People Pleasers.” Hah! I guess at the time she knew something I didn’t.

    But looking back now I just have to laugh at the whole experience. Meeting up with a group of at least fifty or more, once a week in a church basement filled with lesbians, homosexuals, sex addicts(men and women alike), you name it, all the while a transvestite played and sang hymns on a piano (who, btw, had one killer of a testimony). It was actually quite beautiful, the whole experience… and I think it was because it was so raw, so honest… and you know what? Jesus was there. I knew He was there because I could sense His presence, when all those people took the time to pray over and for a “People Pleaser” like me:)

    God moves in mysterious ways.

  • Anonymous says:

    That’s so correct. So many of us have gone to deeper darker holes and places because of the ability that no one will find out. Well unless they track our IP and history but who can actually do that besides the FBI?

  • JennS says:

    Love this post! I am a Christian who has felt isolated by my own thoughts and feelings for many years. I know what its like to walk in a video store and sneak in the ‘xxx room’ and randomly pick a movie as fast as I can and get out the door. In a city its easier to remain annonymous… no one knew me and knew what video I watched. I also agree that the internet has made it morfe accessible now to remain annonymous. I admit that I have looked at porn and have read erotic stories not as a means to ‘get off’ but as a means of simple pleasure.
    As a Christian woman the guilt that we put on ourselves is often beyond reason for enjoying such things! Did I cause harm to anyone but looking at that movie or the pictures online? Nope! I am a single woman and I watched it alone. It was for me an escape, a release a chance really to view people experiencing pleasure.

    Yes in church we are often annonymous. It is easy to go to church sit in a pew and walk out and no one know anything about u.

    I attended a church the same time I looked at that porn movie. Did anyone know? Of course not! So church can be just as annonymous as anywhere really when u think about it.

  • vicarsyf says:

    I think a lot of us wear masks, particularly in chruch, because we feel like once we’re in Christ we should be perfect or whole. We know that God calls us out as set-apart, a peculiar people. What we need to own is that our peculiarity is just that we recognize (as ttm said) we are flawed and seeking more. But the blood of Christ makes us whole. It’s our acceptance of the Death & Resurrection that sets us apart.

    This post is truly thought-provoking. The analogy could be made with other “vices” or things to which we become addicted as well. We hide behind or in those things to mask our brokenness. But, to paraphrase musician Leonard Cohen, we’re all cracked; it’s how the Light gets in (if we allow it).

    Thanks for sharing.

  • BadjerJim says:

    Agree with you 100% about the anonymity being a huge attraction and draw to Porn. Nobody will know, nobody will find out, The Forbidden Fruit, etc.

    I also believe this is the attraction and success of the Greatest of Marriage Destroyers: the Online Chat Rooms. Without trying to sound either self-righteous or sophomoric, Chat Rooms are playground where one can assume any persona – real or imagined. Worse for those who feign honesty, and develop real friendships in this medium. Why? Because even when brutally honest (and some good can come of this) … even then, it overlooks the simple fact that nobody has bad breath or curlers in their hair in a chat room; nobody is overweight or out of shape in a chat room, and NOBODY has a touchy-bitchy bad day in a chat room (when they do, they simply don’t log on). The illusion is complete: people shine with their best smile and humor, and easily obscure or completely hide their worst. In Virtual Space, you can always find a compassionate shoulder to cry on – especially when you only present one side of the story!

    Not sure I agree at all that churches attract, and/or nurture and thrive on anonymity. If so, then the only reason for attending would be a sense of guilt… which paves the way to missing a Sunday here and there, then more, and finally only showing up for Christmas and Easter. And of course, there are lots of those.

  • dubdynomite says:

    The church would be so much more effective if everyone could be honest about their beliefs, doubts, fears, and struggles without fear of judgment or rejection from everyone else.

    Christians need to figure out what real humility is. Most seem overly concerned with what they can find wrong with others, not because they want to help others, but because it makes them feel better about themselves.

    We also need to realize that we are not always going to agree about everything. We need to be able to love one another, in spite of the fact that we disagree. I’m so tired of people that get their panties in a bunch when they find out that Joe likes to have a beer every now and then, that Sally likes to watch some certain tv show, or that Buddy is a fan of ‘secular’ music.

    I may not like what you do, or agree with what you believe, but that doesn’t mean that I cannot be your friend and that we can’t relate.

    Jesus loved us and gave himself for us in spite of what he knew about us. He saved us and blessed us even when he knew that we would fail him. We need to be able to love past knowledge.

  • Stephen says:

    There’s a great quote from Larry Crabb that says, “The greatest lie believed today is that one can know God without being known by someone else.” Christianity is about community, and not something we can experience to the fullest by ourselves.

  • Sarah says:

    I’d say that maybe we could define “character” as “who you are when you get to be anonymous.”

    Which scares me just a little.

    word verification:
    shillo: a shoe made of brillo pads.

  • Jesse says:

    MPT, you are right about porn selling a “story.” When acting out, I would often deny myself orgasm for days on end just to keep the fantasy going. Once I had an orgasm I was just another doofus reaching for the kleenex, and I didn’t like that. Looking back at the texts of those fantasies has actually taught me a lot about what I think deep down that my needs are (and they’re not just sex) and how I think they should be filled.

    I’ve found that when I’ve opened up about my story in group settings, as often as not others will find freedom to open up themselves, or at least thank me later for bringing it up. Sometimes it goes sideways, but not always.

  • Joan Ball says:

    @jennifer I think you hit the issue on the head when you wrote:

    “Meeting up with a group of at least fifty or more, once a week in a church basement filled with lesbians, homosexuals, sex addicts(men and women alike), you name it, all the while a transvestite played and sang hymns on a piano (who, btw, had one killer of a testimony). It was actually quite beautiful, the whole experience… and I think it was because it was so raw, so honest… and you know what? Jesus was there. I knew He was there because I could sense His presence, when all those people took the time to pray over and for a “People Pleaser” like me:)”

    Why is it that all of the “overtly broken” people (I will add recovering alcohol and drug abusers, of which I am one) meet in the basement of the church. Wouldn’t it be nice if the safety you describe in the scene above existed on Sunday morning in the sanctuary?

  • vicarsyf says:

    @Joan Ball
    I am with you! All of the “overtly broken” people meet in the basement of the church. Perhaps we should flip it so that those who are willing and open to being authentic, open, and real should meet in the sanctuary regardless of the day or time, and everyone else meet in the basement until they’re ready to come out of hiding. What a concept!

    Blessings to you all. This is a great conversation. Matt, thank you again for the post. It has really made me examine my own hiding places.

  • brgulker says:

    ttm,

    I just wanted to say thanks for your honesty. Your words impacted me deeply.

    I wrote a post on my own blog about your words, actually, in which I said:

    “I realized after reading ttm’s words that in my own way, I’ve also been living anonymously – for many of the same reasons. So the question I want to ask is not, “Are you living anonymously?” (even though that question is obviously important) But “Why are you living anonymously if you are?”

    And what does it say about the church when it’s the last place that people seeking answers want to go?”

    I don’t know what the answers to my own questions are — but thanks for helping figure out that I need to ask them.

  • ttm says:

    @John: I wish you and your wife well on your journey toward truth. I hope we all get there without too many bruises and bumps!

    @Jen: I have moments of optimism when I really believe, like you, that by dropping my own masks and being open with others, they will feel free to do the same. And then I have those “darker” moments where I think, “What the heck have I done by opening up to these people?” I guess it’s all part of being stretched and transformed.

    @vicarsyf: Do you think we stay cracked? Or do you think that Christ’s blood makes us whole once and for all, so the cracks are only illusions to us?

    @brgulker: I’m glad that my questions/words are inviting your questions/words to dance. It’s nice to “meet” you. Your blog looks interesting… and I’ll probably check back every now and then.

    @MPT: I forgot to say it before, but the analogy between the porn industry and the church machine is nothing short of genius. You should write a book or something! ;^)

  • vicarsyf says:

    @ttm I think we stay cracked, not because we aren’t healed but because we continue to sin. God’s forgiveness heals one crack, our sin creates another. And a lot of good comes from those cracks. The light of Christ comes in to work on us, and the glow of His light can be seen by others through those very same cracks. Thanks for the question; you made me think that through in a way I had not before.

  • ttm says:

    @vicarsyf: Thanks for your answer. It makes a lot of sense.

  • Callum says:

    Good post Matthew.

    Thanks.

    C!

  • Drew Tatusko says:

    thanks matthew. well done. i started a little comment here, but it exploded a bit. so it’s here: new post: names and power http://bit.ly/3tYmbL

    peace.
    drew

  • PJ Savage says:

    I didn’t read all of the comments, so if someone said this already I apologize. In one of John Eldredge’s books (I think Wild at Heart) he talks about the draw of the online lifestyle was that it was easy. There was no risk of intimacy or relationship. Having grown my relationship with Jesus in a larger church I could definitely see the opportunities people had to walk the halls like you described walking around the bookstore, head down and eyes straight ahead. I guess the real challenge is for the person to choose vulnerability in order to build relationships. Otherwise, I agree with you, that we do walk around anonymously.

  • diane says:

    WONDERFUL, WONDERFUL POST!

    As the wife of a recovering addict of pornography, I applaud this post. My husband says he completely understands what you were talking about. MPT, whether or not you have struggled with this issue, you wrote about it beautifully.

    I have never looked at pornography, however, when I was a teen, I did some of the chatting you talked about. I was 14-15, born with a cleft-lip pallet (so I’d always been labeled as different/special needs and laughed at because of my looks. However, in the chat world, I was blonde, tan (I’ve never been tan – my skintone is as white as a sheet of paper), 32, with double d boobs. Oh my goodness, men liked that image. They lusted over this image I created via the internet, and – it made me feel good. Great, even. They wanted me… or at least, who they thought was me. They said things to me that younger girls should never hear, but I didn’t care. I had their attention, I had their heart – or at least something. I particuarly remember one guy telling me he was waiting for his wife to get home, but needed an internet quicky to “get ready for her.” So, I went along with it. I never participated – I just pretended I was, and said all the right things. Then, when our “time” was finished, the guys left, and I signed off the computer and became the regular teenager. The main reason I stopped was the thought one day of, “What would the people at church think about me if they knew the real me – that I did this?”

    Although, you know what? That question still lives inside of me. Not with internet chatting… but with the everyday stuff. I sit next to these people at church daily, and they don’t know what is going on with me. I even struggle with this issue – to some degree – with my own husband. What if he finds out who I really am? Won’t he leave me? [The answer is no, but it doesn’t mean I don’t still struggle and wrestle with that question.] As a church body, we need to recognize the hurting people of the world and help them. We need to make them realize they won’t be judged, they can have a safe environment, and – no matter what – Jesus loves them for who they are. Jesus chose them to be His people, and we don’t need to clean up or whatever to come to Him. He loves us for the broken people we are…

    Sorry this is so long. Again, WONDERFUL.

  • Xian_D says:

    Very odd, I’m sorry if i didn’t continue reading all of the comments, but I’m fairly tired of having My Youth from my congregation Lives anonymous lives… Its saddening but I’ve done so much…

    I’m stepped into that some think as a plague, having an Open Heart and Truth with Honesty of my Lifestyle and Sins

    To My encounter with God and Jesus I know having my Soul and Heart being read isn’t an Easy Thing…

    But for me to say anything I’d give my name for something much more…

    People say those who blended in they are anonymous, I find it more My Lively to be there… but No Named and Faced…

    It doesn’t make sense, and surely it will never will…

    But i found it easier to believe in We’re In This Together, Our Lives, Our Days, Our Deaths…

    So for me, I’d give up that anonymous lifestyle Yes, when directed or pointed to Sin…

    and have that anonymous life just like any other human being with a heart…

    just like God, Give Love, Give care, Give Grace no matter who I am…

  • BeckyMPH says:

    This, to me, is about our competing desires. For all the parts of us that want to be transparent and vulnerable and known, there are also parts of us that want to retreat and to be hidden.

    The hope of acceptance battles against the fear of rejection.

    This is true as it relates to church and also to sex, and to many other areas of our lives.

  • Brad Ruggles says:

    Dang Matthew, that’s good stuff there. I love the comparison of the church to the porn industry because, although most of us would never make the connection, it’s so very true. Definitely something to think about.

    Excellent post. This one is getting bookmarked.

  • Anonymous says:

    Great stuff, absolutely needed to be said. On that note…

    I reckon I’ve experienced anonymity since graduating from college. All of the people who know me (except for my wife) live over two hours away from me, as I took a job at a church right after graduation. I’ve been here 7 years, and boy, do I know what it’s like to be anonymous. I know what it’s like for people to see you based on only what you can provide them and not who you are. There are very few people here who have tried to get to know us, and trust me, we aren’t hard to get to know.

    We just stick out like sore thumbs.

    So, I suppose I can relate with the longing for acceptance. I love working in the church, but I am in desperate need of community as well, and I wish I didn’t have to drive over 2 hours to get it.

  • Anonymous says:

    I like the analogy, but I think porn addiction is pretty simple. I was reading “the omnivore’s dilemma” recently (great book) and Michael Pollan had a very simple explanation for why Americans are so fat. Our bodies are designed to crave high energy food. In a primitive setting, this feature of our taste buds, would be very advantageous for humans finding food that would make them stronger and give them energy. In our American society, now that we have abundant access to any and all types of food, this feature of our taste buds makes us prefer calorie rich food and ends up making us fat. In the same way, our bodies are designed to have a high level of sexual energy. Again, this sexual energy is useful in motivating humans to reproduce. Trust me, there are times in my life when I wish I wasn’t so attracted to crazy women. Capitalism and technology have now come up with abundant ways of fulfilling our sexual desires; desires that are very natural and necessary.

    I have a taste for naked women just like I have a taste for chocolate cake. And you can’t convince me that Jennifer Garner wouldn’t enjoy a donut right now, or that the Pope couldn’t have a good time at the Playboy mansion. The problem is that it’s way too easy to find lots of naked women and lots of chocolate cake. If I spend my life pursuing these simple cravings, I’ll wind up fat and unloved. I suppose I’ll have some good times along the way, but there’s a much more satisfying way to live my life. What’s healthy are natural foods and real love; not sugar and sex.

    And in the spirit of being real, it’s tough to want to eat carrots and DTR when there’s cake and Megan Fox just sitting out there. Sometimes I wish i lived in a more primitive world.

  • Anonymous says:

    This post was interesting to read… and made me think alot… as someone who spent many years in the church judging those who struggled with this, and many other sins, I’ve come to a place where a blanket acceptance is a much more beautiful and peaceful place to come from. I accept those for who they are, and don’t think it is my job anymore to “fix” and “convert” people. I’ve in fact watched a porn because I was curious, didn’t seem like it was for me, and haven’t again. It wasn’t the big scary addicting sin that I imagined it to be. Unfortunately the church is full of intolerance and judgment, and I refuse to be a part of it any longer. Living real is next to impossible in the church. And I want to live real. I understand the addiction and lure of porn is a very real problem in society, and in church, and agree that anonymity is likely a large part of it. So is the lure of intimacy. We crave intimacy and sex or the next best thing gives us that connection. Even if for a moment. I wish all those who have posted peace, love and acceptance in your journey.

  • Anonymous says:

    First, thanks for this post, I needed it to help me maintain my semblance of purity. One day at a time and all that. The internet is not necessarily my problem, but it sure doesn’t help.

    I think the barrier people face with admitting to certain problems is not just that others will find out something about you that you wished didn’t exist, but that you don’t want all the people in the congregation to think you betrayed them. Even if you never did anyone any harm (tho see my next paragraph). Then again, pretending your own problem doesn’t exist might mean that you never help someone else with their deep-dark-secret.

    JennS (tho I do feel hypocritical for posting anon myself), in the grand scheme of things, a little bit of porn might not do long term damage to your thought processes, present and future relationships, etc. But that porn definitely has already damaged the people involved in creating it. And yes, that’s more hypocrisy because in my mind I can do a lot of self-justification for my own sins.

    Finally, finally. Though it’s a slightly different issue from the original post, the internet is not as anonymous as you think. A determined person could easily piece together a lot of information about you. Yeah, I fear.

  • Easily the best post I’ve ever read about porn. Thanks for writing it.

    For me, porn (and almost any other struggle in my life) is about control. I love the illusion of being fully in control of a situation. In life, the reality is that I am never in control God always is. But the great lie is that I can be in control, I can “do it my way” as Frank Sinatra sang.

    I appreciate your honesty, your openness, and your heart. I pray that all of us would start the journey toward actual, off-line honesty and transparency with somebody. Let’s use the internet as our starting point. I see so many people in the comments here that would kill (metaphorically) for a chance to have a real, honest relationship offline, in their church. Be the friend you want, and risk the rejection or ostracism.

    MPT, I hope you are as cool and open in real life as you seem on this blog.

  • The Journeys says:

    The last few paragraphs truly hit home. Especially in the age of the mega church trying to find a group of people with whom you can open up and be yourself with. The online cmty (facebk, myspace, twitter) is such a huge part of our lives that it does not surprise me that the feeling of belonging is found on online. It is now a question of what are we as the body of Christ going to do