Skip to main content

Why Hershel might be the most important Christian on TV #WalkingDead

By November 12, 2013Blog

Hershel-faith-Christian

**FYI: THIS POST CONTAINS SPOILERS**

“Being a hero takes a lot out of you.” That’s what Hershel said in Sunday night’s episode of The Walking Dead.

And in that episode, Hershel was indeed a hero.

As a huge fan of The Walking Dead, I’ve grown to love and admire Hershel. For one thing, he’s a bad ass.

If you watched Sunday night’s “Internment”–the title of episode 4 of The Walking Dead’s fourth season–then you know this to be true: Don’t mess with Hershel. Amid caring for the sick and encouraging those who were dying, Hershel also managed to kill a dozen or so walkers and soon-to-be walkers. He limped up and down those prison hallways shoving knives through the heads of monsters that, just moments before, had been humans, friends, comrades that he was trying to save from the flu outbreak. Sure, we already knew he was badass. I mean, the oldest inhabitant of the prison has most certainly faced his helping of apocalyptic crazy–everything from loss to frightening zombie attacks to that leg amputation to the ongoing antics of Carl. But in last night’s episode, Hershel took “spry” to a whole new level.

But that’s not the only reason I love Hershel.

The big reason is because, with Hershel’s character, the Walking Dead writers are recasting what it means to be the token “Christian” on a wildly popular television show. Because in the course of three seasons, the writers have grown and shaped “Hershel” into one of the most believable, most compelling, and most beautiful representations of Christianity on television in a long time. But why does Hershel’s faith work on The Walking Dead? Here’s why I think it does…

It’s presented with subtlety. Against hopelessness and fear, a little bit of God goes a long long way. On Sunday night, we watched Hershel survive hell. When it was over, we see him weeping in his cell, resting in his hands is his Bible… open. We need no more than that to understand what he’s feeling, what he’s searching for. Church people could learn a thing or two about being subtle from The Walking Dead writers.

It’s infused with humor and irony. One of my favorite Walking Dead quotes was uttered by Hershel. In the finale of season 2, after a swarm of zombies had completely overtaken his farm, Rick and Hershel engaged in this conversation:

Rick said, “You’re a man of God. Have some faith.”
Hershel sighed, “I can’t profess to understand God’s plan, Christ promised the resurrection of the dead. I just thought he had something a little different in mind.” (SOURCE)

Against the context of Hershel’s “reality,” that quote was writing brilliance. Because it not only spoke to his situational plight, it also shed light on just how uncertain about things Hershel had become. And no doubt, if put in his circumstances, we’d feel the same way.

It’s realistically conveyed. Hershel’s faith has changed since we first met him in season 2. Then, he wasn’t the most likable of characters. And a good part of his unlikable personality was because he was a Christian, a man whose faith had been shaken by the reality of zombies. Still, despite his reality throwing a wrench in what he believes to be true, he attempts to keep his faith alive through judgment, control, and soundbites. And how realistic is that? How often does our own faith get reduced to symptoms of fear when life doesn’t turn out the way we believed it would or should. And that’s how Hershel’s walk with God was portrayed early on, in the way he threw around his weight, in how he avoided some relationships and attempted to micro-manage others. Early on, Hershel was just an angry fundamentalist who possessed a miraculous incapability of self-awareness. But the writers didn’t leave him there. Life changed Hershel. It soften his approach. It left him with more questions than answers. And yet, still believing, still searching…

It’s relevant. The writers use Hershel’s faith to bring weight and humanity and depth to the trials and tribulations that Rick & company encounter. Nowhere was this more beautifully portrayed than when Hershel reads aloud Psalm 91 toward the end of season 3.

It’s not a crutch. Since Hershel often represents the “moral center” of the group–the show’s inspirational Buddha–it would be easy for the writers to allow Hershel’s faith to limit or set boundaries around his characterization. But they mostly avoid that by breaking the rules for what it means to have faith in the zombied world. Hershel isn’t in everybody’s business, trying to control people’s actions, and he doesn’t bring up God in every conversation or when it’s not appropriate to do so.

And somehow, all of that makes Hershel’s Christianity work.

Sure, Hershel is just a television character on a crazy farfetched TV show. But in a popular culture that often portrays Christians only as shallow flamboyant rightwing nutjobs, Hershel stands out, not because he’s the ideal persona of Christ but because he isn’t and you never get the sense that he’s trying to be. It’s refreshing to watch a faith-based character whose religiosity isn’t forced or cheesy and rarely presented with total certainty or finality. Instead, amid life’s crazy, Hershel seems to be searching for wisdom, hope, and understanding.

And maybe that’s the real reason Hershel’s character works: because he’s a lot like us or how we hope to be.

Viagra is for the treatment of inability to get or keep an hard-on and similar states when erection is of low quality. When you buy remedies like cialis from canada you should know about cialis online canada. It may have a lot of brands, but only one ATC Code. Erectile disfunction, defined as the persistent impossibility to maintain a satisfactory hard-on, affects an estimated 15 to 30 millions men in the America alone. Sexual health is an substantial part of a man’s life, no problem his age etc.

Matthew Paul Turner

Author Matthew Paul Turner

More posts by Matthew Paul Turner

Join the discussion 18 Comments

  • zachhoag says:

    Dude, agree 100%. And I have to say with the last two episodes, this show is officially BACK.

  • DannyEason says:

    Love this, Matthew!!

  • rickosaurus_tex says:

    Hershel and The Walkers would be a great name for a band.  Lots of pop culture fodder there.  But seriously…great thoughts here.

  • This was beautifully written and something that, as someone who ISN’T a Christian, I can completely agree with and understand.

  • zparry says:

    I’m just wondering what makes Hershel a Christian? Is it that he has a Bible and mentioned Christ in an episode? Mormons and Jehovah’s Witness’s also use the Bible and believe in a version of Christ even though they are separate from Christianity. The walking dead is probably my favorite show, and I am a Christian – so I’m not just trying to argue. But I think the reason so many people don’t understand Christianity is because we call everyone a Christian. Being a Christian means believing that Jesus Christ, being fully man and God, lived a perfect life, died in our place for the payment of sin, and was resurrected, so that if we believe in him we will have eternal life. Until Hershel talks about that on the Walking Dead, we’re just assuming he’s a Christian based on outward appearance. And that contributes to fake Christianity.

  • zparryQuote from Hershel in season 2: “Stop telling me how to care for my family, my farm. You people are
    like a plague! I do the Christian thing, give you shelter, and you
    destroyed it all” So regardless how you define “Christian,” the writers of the TV show give no indication that Hershel is Mormon or JW. And chances are, they would, since that would define his character substantially.

  • frognparis says:

    This ALMOST makes me watch Walking Dead. If I could only like zombies…

  • JTAdamson says:

    MPT:
    This post of yours makes me deeply bitter and resentful because it brings to light the harsh truth: I haven’t seen even 2 minutes of The Walking Dead. I’d love to, but given my current state of busy-ness, it’s not going to happen.
    Darn you.
    But that’s good news for you, because, in the last few years, whenever I decide to start watching a sci-fi/fantasy show, it gets canceled.  I’m not superstitious, just observant.
    Thanks for giving me a peek into The Walking Dead.  The Terminator TV series had some overt Christian overtones from the start, and an overtly Christian character.  But I killed that show.

  • JDSarginson says:

    My favorite representation of Hershel’s faith is in his insistence that “everyone has a job.”  Often times, he’s also able to tell the person he’s talking to that, “this one’s yours.”  The only reason he is able to do this with such certainty (but still without coercion) is that he knows the people he’s talking to, and he has a vision and a hope for the thriving and flourishing of the group – whether they share his faith or not.  He encourages and supports and champions the idea of community, knowing that people are most alive when they give themselves away to others.  Surrounded by death, the only hope of life is found in people who share, work together, sacrifice, and love.  And he even insists on the part people have to play when they have given up hope, or when they no longer believe in their value.
    “Now if the foot should say, ‘Because I am not a hand, I do not belong to the body,’ it would not for that reason stop being part of the body…”
    And of course, the antithesis of this is expressed in the Governor, who promised throughout season 3 to provide safety and security for the low, low price of blind allegiance.  My own thoughts about the sloppiness of his character and the story-line aside, this juxtaposition between “Kingdoms” was right on.

  • doodad says:

    I’m just curious why he is thought to be a Christian.  Maybe he’s just religious.  Has he done anything specifically Christian?

  • Completely agree. I have often thought, “I wish my faith was like his, real and a little goofy!”

  • paulvanderklay says:

    Hershel is one of my favorite characters in this show and I agree it is an outstanding program. 
    Overall I think religion is one of the aspects that the series has fallen down on. The author of the graphic novel noted his reason for the work: “With the Walking Dead I want to explore how people deal with extreme situations and how these situations CHANGE them.” If you know anything about people under stress you know that the area of religion is one of the chief ways people change under stress. People abandon their religion, double down on it, change it, nuance it, etc. The show is actually TOO secular in my opinion. It would be an excellent place to explore religion. 
    I think the reason it doesn’t, and the reason a number of commentators here ask about how specifically Christian Hershel is (Mormon, JW, Baptist, Calvinist, not RC apparently…) a few comments and the repeated Bible citing with him. Also not much processing of religion with his daughters. The American media mass market wants to steer clear of specifics. The Bible seems safe to touch upon if we keep things loose enough but I’d like to see fully religious characters here as they process the calamity they live within. 
    This also gives a window into what the writers imagine a non-offensive Christian is and therefore its not only a barometer of cultural acceptance but also a groomer of cultural sensitivities. 
    If the writers want to get serious about the religious aspect of people and communities they’re going to have to take more risks. They already have numerous good and bad thinly religious characters. You should have really religious people who are hypocritical jerks across the religious spectrum while also having some gems like Hershel. This is how we are. 
    Thanks for highlighting this and creating a space to discuss it.

  • lightposte07 says:

    I dunno… The show felt like it was promoting Atheism and mocking Christianity.
    Just when you think Hershel’s the one who would help Rick relieve his doubt — it turns out that the writers made Hershel just another religious mindless lunatic (isn’t that how some atheist view Christians?) and that he’s better off renouncing his faith.